2011-07-15

The 14th amendment and the possible government shutdown

Oh dear:
Crisis talks on the United States' debt limit remained deadlocked overnight as negotiations led by US president Barack Obama degenerated into a slanging match.

The president is said to have stalked out of the latest debt talks, which both sides have acknowledged as the most heated yet.

"This may bring my presidency down, but I will not yield on this," Mr Obama is quoted as saying.

The prospects of politicians reaching a deal to raise the debt ceiling are still in question after fifth straight day of talks.
Some econ bloggers have pointed out that the 14th Amendment of the United States renders the "debt ceiling" unconstitutional:
The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any State shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave. But all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void.

My view is that the "debt ceiling" is not unconstitutional. What is unconstitutional is to default on this debt. Let me explain.

All the "debt ceiling" does is prevent the government from borrowing any more money beyond the previous predetermined limit. Since congress has the power under the constitution to legislate borrowing and spending bills, any self imposed limit on the amount of money the federal government borrows is entirely within their purview.

So what happens when congress doesn't increase the debt limit a "government shutdown" is initiated?

All it means is that the government will have to cut spending in order to fit into the amount of money they do receive. Spending must be cut. And if we believe that the 14th amendment will be followed, then we can assume that paying back interest and principal on money borrowed will not be affected at all. Instead, spending cuts will be made to other areas of government control. Spending on health care will be cut drastically. Military spending could possibly be cut. Social Security spending cuts would only occur if the spending is not considered "government debt".

My spreadsheet tells me the following about US government debts and receipts:


So if revenue represents 16.61% of GDP and spending represents 25.29% of GDP, then any failure to increase the debt ceiling will force the federal government into spending only as much as it gets. This would mean 16% spending instead of 25% spending. In short, it would reduce the spending size of government by around two-fifths. You can imagine how devastating such an action would be upon the economy.

But what about government debt? The last time I checked, interest paid on government debt made up around 2.8% of GDP. Even after a potential failure to increase the debt ceiling, interest on treasury bonds and other debts will have ample room to be paid back.

A failure to raise the debt ceiling will most certainly shrink government spending, but it will not result in debt default. The unemployed will no longer be given payments, Medicare will grind to a halt, NASA will disappear, even social security has the potential to be scaled back... but at least those who lent the government money will get their interest - hardly a cause for celebration.

To summarise the 14th amendment on this issue: The amendment doesn't invalidate a debt ceiling, it just ensures that government debt will be paid off even if any debt ceiling isn't increased.

60 comments:

Info World said...

Thanks for sharing a great article.
You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
Keep posting like this informative articles.
Thank you.

Get to know about 123movies

온라인카지노 said...

What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this website
regularly, this web page is really good and the users
are in fact sharing nice thoughts.


카지노사이트
온라인카지노
카지노사이트추천

온라인카지노 said...

I have express a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorite’s blog site list and will be checking back soon…




카지노사이트
바카라사이트
카지노사이트홈

온라인카지노 said...

토토사이트
토토사이트추천
토토 대표 사이트


Simply want to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is just great and i could assume you’re an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work.

온라인카지노 said...

토토
안전놀이터
메이저사이트 목록




I really like it when folks come together and share opinions.
Great website, keep it up!

totosite365.info said...

Fantastic site. Lots of helpful information here. 스포츠토토

slotmachine777.site said...

I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. Many thanks. 릴게임

badugisitenet said...

Great Post, Thanks for sharing wonderful information.Like it! 온라인바둑이

pachinkosite.info said...

You definitely put a new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great! 토토사이트

texasholdemsite.info said...

I think this article has a lot of information needed, looking forward to your new posts. 배트맨토토덤

mary said...

Gambling without the risk of being caught is known that, as we all know, playing online gambling games that no one can know. We do not have to worry about being caught because we do not gamble at the casino and can play anywhere, anytime through a mobile phone or computer only. ambbet

Sandee said...

Playing games at pg will make you enjoy playing games and playing games here are for sure real money. So if you don't want to be disappointed with gambling games, come to pg because there are games. Easy to play slots and has a relatively high payout rate. pgslot

namwan said...

Deposit money top up promotion 50 get 100 for all members, you can deposit money top up promotion 50 get 100 on the web. with the opportunity to make a simple turn slotxo

บาคาร่า said...

ach of them works, and if you were to ask about usability, you wouldn't have to talk about it because there are wa ambbet

Zugurwan said...

Choosing a team in a smaller league but must not be too small for betting Which in addition to helping you have a complete set of teams for betting, it also increases your chances of getting money. ambbet

Onepiece said...

ambbet 100% bonus that is given to you without quarantine at all. Deposit-withdraw, no minimum, no hassle of sending slips. superslot เครดิตฟรี

TT said...

And most importantly, online slot games have images. beautiful graphics attractive as well
How to play online slot games online slot games superslot เครดิตฟรี

popo said...

You can come to bet on slots games correctly and increase your chances. To generate good income is another channel as well. pgslot

วุ้นเส้น said...

Roulette, all kinds of sports games, including e-sports, are available for you to bet on. It can be said that you just play in the AMB game camp. amb

aom2536 said...

TAISHANG LAOJUN that is a game online Chinese theme review for you. Let's see how the review will be. Let's go see it. Game details TAISHANG LAOJUN TAISHANG LAOJUN game is an online game cre สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

GUN said...

The most popular games in our camp would be none other than online slots games and can tell. ambbet

Onepiece said...

PG SLOT Direct access to the web slot game Newest opening 2022 welcome everyone สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

jamji said...

is the best choice For all gamblers that can play Both computers and PCs can be downloaded via mobile phone apps. that can be installed easily and quickly pgslot

SST said...

Exclusive online competition that is above the level that cannot be played anywhere else. pgslot

Sandee said...

Vitamin C contains substances that help to prevent the degeneration of cells in the body, especially the cells of the eyeball. สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg

arisa060340 said...

which playing online slots games Chat as a help in solving the gap. that before playing online slots pgslot

pgslot said...

And in the game with minimal errors. that the admin has used with online web games in order to be convenient
pgslot

HANAKA555 said...

Hello, admin has something to inform you.
in a short time We will have a combination of brands.
We will combine all GIANT - GIJ - GLI - together at Giant GAB. pgslot

Sandee said...

Eliminate odors should find the source of these odors first. what caused Because these smells are not only musty. amb

ambbetambbet said...

Free credit is another important technique for playing online slots games. But that you can win at online slots games. ข่าวบอลล่าสุด

Onepiece said...

Fish shooting game for real money Easy to play and withdraw. As a result, the game was created more and more. pgslot เว็บตรง

Michael said...

Online slots promotions and fish shooting games, both brands pgslot, great promotions, free credit, hot promotion pgslot เว็บตรง

pgslot said...

This will make bettors confident.
including all camps including all websites free credit no deposit สล็อต

mowan said...

importantly, this game camp has a very high payout rate. It is a gambling game where everyone is always looking for a chance of success for spinning the wheel. pgslot

Onepiece said...

Player side and Banker side The gambler had to guess which side would have more points. ตารางคะแนนพรีเมียร์ลีก

pacto said...

to provide services that meet the needs of the players as to provide services that meet the needs of the players as pgslot เว็บตรง

pattap said...

Experience the real playing, just as you will improve your betting skills and get bonuses pgslot

pgslot said...

In which Ambbet Wallet, we have selected international quality sports betting websites. pgslot

pgslot said...

turn slots Solve all doubts Why do you have to make a turn? Don't wait. Hurry up to apply. ข่าวบอลล่าสุด

น้ำตาล said...

Many PG slots testers tend to turn on the brightest light from the screen. whether on mobile or computer In addition to causing loss of sight superslot

Noud said...

Online Slots Articles Collection of online slots articles for everyone to study the pattern and how to play including slot formulas that increases the chances of doing สล็อต

pgslot said...

With a game system developed to be modern, easy to play beautiful light images with a variety of themes to play with pgslot

วุ้นเส้น said...

is the largest bonus amount and the hardest to break This bonus is up to 400 times your stake. which if you bet high ดูบอลสด

Onepiece said...

The advantages of the direct web Quick and convenient, it doesn't take long most comfortable สล็อต

pgslot said...

Sign up and try all slots for free.
Our website has compiled all slots trial services in the camp. superslot

Anonymous said...

in a Return to Player that requires personalization.

3. The wild symbol, also known as the ถ่ายทอดสดบอลวันนี้

punrice said...

In order to deposit and withdraw, you will have to sit back and calculate. Join us here. Good service, no lack of falls, absolute glitches! pgslot

arisa060340 said...

And for new gamblers, they may not know how different the past and present slot games are. superslot

Onepiece said...

Dare to guarantee from our web users all over the country that it's really good for our website. pgslot

น้ำตาล said...

rosemary scent cool aroma of herbs Helps the brain feel clear. Relax from stress and worry. It helps with memory and stimulates the circulatory system as well. สล็อตxo

popcron said...

Let's race for real on the field in this online horse racing game. It was like watching a sporting event. and waiting to win สล็อต

beem said...

Watch football online, watch TV online Today's football schedule Live table Live football program ดูบอลออนไลน์

mimi said...

Using yoga techniques makes it possible to retrain the muscles. Most tennis athletes play in a consta ดูบอลออนไลน์

pp1 said...

dooballsod

pp1 said...

ดูบอลสด

pp1 said...

fórmula de tragamonedas hacer dinero real Si alguien está buscando una fórmula para ganar dinero Obtenga ganancias en juegos de tragamonedas de calidad slotxo

pp1 said...

Algunas técnicas son ineficaces. También hace que los jugadores usen su dinero apostado en vano. สล็อตออนไลน์

Noud said...

newest slots website that we have opened for service right now. If anyone has not applied joker123

pp1 said...

Tricks to play slots to get a pantip bonus that actually works high security to increase the chances of winning the game บอลนะจ๊ะ

breekelly said...

file ///sdcard/images, or videos are not showing up in the file;///sdcard/gallery directory it could be due, to the presence of a .nomedia file.